I buy and try a ridiculous amount of cosmetic products. I’m always reading up on the newest releases, beauty news, and industry conversations. Despite amassing such a large makeup collection, I work hard to use what I own. One benefit to owning so much makeup is that I have the opportunity to try a ton of different formulas. Within this Makeup Collection Series, I am showcasing and ranking all the items in my collection, by category.
In today’s ranking, I will be discussing my Lip Gloss collection. As with all posts in this series, I’ll include swatches of each gloss in my collection, as well as prices, and mini-reviews.
Please keep reading to see what I own and where each lip liner ranks in my collection.
My lip gloss collection ranking will be done by formula or brand rather than ranking each individual gloss. As always, these are ranked from least favorite to most favorite.
Lip Gloss Collection
Lip Gloss Collection & Ranking
16 | ColourPop x Disney Villains Ultra Glossy Lip – Puppies!!! (CF, $7.00 USD)
Sadly, the ColourPop x Disney Villains Ultra Glossy Lips were my biggest lip product disappointment of 2019. The formula is too metallic, extremely sticky, drying, and generally unflattering on the lips. Beyond these issues, I dislike the brush applicator tip.
I’m glad to have received the Flower Beauty Galaxy Glaze Gloss at Beautycon LA because this is a transformative gloss. However, the light purple tint and sticky finish makes me less inclined to reach for this gloss.
Flower Beauty, Natasha Denona, Urban Decay, Shared Planet, and Givenchy
14 | Natasha Denona Lip Glaze in Antique Rose & Wooden Rose ($22.00 USD, CF)
When the Natasha Denona Lip Glazes went on sale at Sephora, I could not risk the temptation to try the formula. I purchased the shades Antique Rose and Wooden Rose based on online swatches I saw. Unfortunately, Antique Rose and Wooden Rose look milky on my lips so I need to pair these glosses with darker lipsticks or lip liners.
From a formula standpoint, the Natasha Denona Lip Glosses feel stickier than others on this list. They are not as sticky as previous glosses that I’ve decluttered, but it is less comfortable than others included on this list.
I discovered Shared Planet in 2019 after being bombarded with ads on YouTube; however, I am happy to have discovered this new brand. Shared Planet donates a portion of all sales to charities that work to save and preserve Polar Bears and Tigers.
The Polar Bear Bundle contains an icy white shade, Wintry and Hudson Bay, a deep mauve. While I enjoy the colors of these glosses, the formula feels stickier than most of the other glosses on this list. Wintry is stickier than Hudson Bay
Il Makiage, Shared Planet, Natasha Denona & More!
12 | Iconic London Lip Plumping Lip Gloss in Nearly Nude ($26.00 USD, CF)
Iconic London is a newer brand to me that I tried for the first time in 2019 after receiving a product in my October Boxycharm. In particular, the Lip Plumping Lip Gloss is the first Iconic London product I tried from the brand.
The Lip Plumping Lip Gloss feels cooling on the lips, but I don’t notice a huge plumping effect on the lip. However, I enjoy the color and the formula does feel nice on the lips.
11 | Stila Beauty Boss Lip Gloss in Kitten ($24.00 USD, CF)
The Urban Decay Hi-Fi Shine Ultra Cushion Lip Gloss is such an underrated formula. I own the shade, Rapture, which is a beautiful rose mauve color.
Pat McGrath Labs, Dose of Colors, Glossier, & Bite Beauty
8 | Il Makiage x Carli Bybel High Shine Lip Glaze – Star Child & Twilight (CF, $19.00 USD)
My Il Makiage x Carli Bybel glosses are easily the most beautifully packaged glosses in my collection. They look visually stunning and feel weighted.
More importantly, the High Shine Lip Glaze formula is a sheer, glittery gloss that acts as a perfect, transformative lip topper over top any lip liner or lipstick. These are not the most long lasting, but they do feel comfortable.
Unfortunately, this collection is no longer available. Hopefully we’ll see similarly packaged lip glazes from the brand.
Kylie Cosmetics High Gloss Collection
7 | Kylie Cosmetics High Glosses (CF, $16.00 USD)
Contrary to what you may think about reading this list – I love my Kylie High Glosses. These are some of my favorite glosses… which is why I own so many shades. My lips look luscious and plump, but these glosses are just a tad bit stickier than some of the others on this list. Read my full review of the High Glosses.
Bite Beauty understands how to make high quality lip products. The brand’s Dirty Chai French Press Lip Gloss is a lovely, pigmented burnt brownish nude gloss. I love wearing this gloss during the colder months.
The Clear Lip Glossfrom Glossier is one of the glosses that helped to usher glossy lips back into pop culture in the US. This is the ultimate clear gloss – very high shine and versatile. This isn’t sticky, per se, but it is stickier than some of the below formulas. Read my brand review of Glossier’s cult classic products.
Dose of Colors Lip Gloss – On Repeat & Seriously Taupe
4 | Dose of Colors Lip Glosses – On Repeat & Seriously Taupe (CF, $17.00 USD)
My Dose of Colors Lip Glosses are my favorite opaque gloss formula. These glosses are non-sticky, comfortable, and easy to apply. Compared to the other glosses in my collection, these are the most pigmented. The shades On Repeat & Seriously Taupe are closer in color than I thought they’d be based on Ulta’s color guide.
3 | Pat McGrath Labs Mini Lust Gloss Trio($25.00 USD, CF)
The Pat McGrath Labs Lust Glosses may not look impressive in the tube, but these glosses are ultra-high shine. The Lust Glosses are pigmented enough to wear on their own, but can easily be worn overtop another lip liner or lipstick.
Pat McGrath Labs Lust Gloss Lip Gloss Trio
Pat McGrath makes it easy to try the Lust Gloss formula through the countless mini bundles available on her site. I own the Warm Mini Lust Gloss Trio, but there are other variations available.
Given that I own every shade in the Persona Cosmetics lip gloss line, it should go without saying that I love this formula. These glosses are a thin formula that feels hydrating and non-sticky. The glosses are pigmented, but not in a way that is overpowering. Read my full review of these glosses.
I am hooked on the Fenty Beauty Gloss Bomb formula. These glosses feel hydrating and creamy on my lips. They work well on their own, but wear well on their own, too. My lips look so luscious and plump when I wear these two glosses. Well worth the high price tag.
Do I need all these lip glosses? No – the color variation between these glosses is not differentiated. However, each formula has its own unique feel and wears differently when paired with various lippies or worn alone. My biggest formula pet peeve is stickiness and short wear-times.
As a whole, I prefer transformative or sheer glosses as opposed to opaque formulas. Moreover, while I love a bold lip, I prefer softer glossy lips so I tend to reach for nude colors when I’m wearing something opaque.
Catch up on the rest of my Beauty Collection Series
Did you enjoy reading about my Brow collection? Keep up with the rest of the posts in this series here:
This error message is only visible to WordPress admins
Warning: The account for thenewburygirl needs to be reconnected. Due to Instagram platform changes on March 2, 2020, this Instagram account needs to be reconnected to allow the feed to continue updating. Reconnect on plugin Settings page