I am a beauty addict who is always looking for the newest releases, beauty news, and industry conversations. Despite owning so much makeup, I do make an effort to use what is in my collection. Given the size of my collection, I have had the opportunity to try a ton of cosmetic formulas. Within this Makeup Collection Series, I am showcasing and ranking all the items in my collection, by category.
Please keep reading for my lip crayon collection ranking.
As always, just because some of the products in my lip crayon collection ranking are listed lower than others does not mean that I dislike the formula or the brand. I love all the lipstick pencils included in my lipstick pencil collection ranking – otherwise, I would not own them!
Lip Pencils are an awesome alternative to a traditional bullet lipstick
Lipstick Pencil Collection Ranking
6 | Reina Rebelde Bold Lip Color in Xicana ($16.00 USD, CF)
I received the Reina Rebelde Bold Lip Color in Xicana for free after attending Beautycon NYC. The shade is a deep, brown-tone that is stunning, but not something I reach for as often as other lip products on this list.
5 | NYX Jumbo Lip Pencil in Pecan ($4.50 USD, CF)
The NYX Jumbo Lip Pencil in Pecan is a beautiful, creamy mauve-nude color. The lip pencil provides a satin, mauve-toned finish. Color-wise, this lip pencil is a dupe for Bite Beauty’s Glace, however, it does not last as long on the lips as Glace.
4 | Nudestix Intense Gel Color Lip + Cheek Balm in Siren ($24.00 USD, CF)
The Nudestix Intense Gel Color Lip + Cheek Balm is a newer Nudestix lip formula that provides the look of a gloss in a pencil format. Siren is a vibrant, high shine red.
The Bite Beauty Matte Creme Lip Pencils are a highly pigmented, long-lasting, comfortable formula. The shade Glace is a stunning mauve-toned nude that I love to reach for on days when I want a simple lip look.
NARS’ lip pencils have been staples in my beauty collection since I first began wearing high-end makeup. The shade Cruella is one that I’ve repurchased over the years because it is a classic, deep red.
As a whole, NudeStix makes one of my favorite lip formulas. I find the brand’s lip products to be pigmented, long-lasting, and non-drying. The matte lip pencil in the shade Vintageis a beautiful, vampy color that adds a glamorous edge to any look.
Lipstick Collection Ranking Swatches
Final Thoughts on My Lipstick Pencil Collection
Compared to my traditional bullet lipsticks, I own very few lip crayons, so my lip crayon collection is quite small. While lip crayons often perform similarly to bullet lipsticks they can provide more precision due to their slender form.
Lip crayons are a wonderful product because they can be worn on their own or used similarly to a lip liner. Looking at my lip crayon collection ranking, it is obvious that I prefer a comfortable matte formula as opposed to the satin or creme finishes.