For the past six months, I’ve been documenting my attempt to follow a strict beauty low buy to reign in my spending. My goal is to stop my beauty collection from rapid expansion.Â Sadly, I have not been successful with my attempts to follow a strict monthly beauty low buy. Keep reading for my 2019 Beauty Low Buy October update.
2019 Beauty Low Buy Rules
After a miserable attempt at a Beauty Low Buy, my Beauty No Buy officially started on November 2nd, 2019. While on this No Buy,Â I cannot purchase any new cosmetics products between the dates of November 2nd, 2019 and November 1st, 2020.Â I am only allowed to buy products if:
- (1) If a product is finished and I don’t have a suitable backup
- (2) If I receive a gift card, I will allow myself to use it, but I cannot purchase extra items that go beyond the value of the gift card. (side note: I have Ulta points I’d like to use before they expire at the end of this year)
- (3) If the Anastasia Amreezy Highlighter comes back in stock and when Melt Releases their Limited Edition Amor Eterno collection.
This No Buy is specific to color cosmetics only – skincare and haircare are not included. I regularly work through my personal care products. I will not be canceling my Boxycharm subscription. Finally, I am still allowed to receive beauty-related gifts from friends and family or products from brands for testing purposes.
Please keep reading for a summary of what I wanted to buy in October, but did not purchase. Also, included is a summary of what I actually bought last month.
What I Wanted to Buy in October (but Didn’t)
The below are products that piqued my interest over the last month in my beauty low buy:
Chanel – Poudre Lumiere Highlighter Eclat Manietique de Chanel
The Chanel Poudre Lumiere Highlighter looks so classically beautiful, from the highlighter color to the design imprint in the pan and to the packaging. One day I hope to own some Chanel products. If the highlighter comes to Macy’s, I may save up to purchase this with my current gift cards to the famous department store.
Natasha Denona – Metropolis Palette | $129.00
When I first saw the promo pictures for the Natasha Denona Metropolis Palette,* I wasn’t sure if I was drawn to the color scheme. However, the more I’ve looked at this palette… the more I’ve been drawn to it. From the reviews, I’ve read (and watched), people seem to love this palette and speak highly of how creamy the mattes feel. However, in looking at the swatches, I’m confident I own these colors in other palettes.
What I Actually Bought in October
If I’m being honest with myself, I intended to start my No Buy on October 1st, 2019, but I pushed it back once Anastasia Beverly Hills, ColourPop, and Fenty decided to come for my wallet with their October releases.
As with every other month, I failed to keep my beauty low buy in October because I purchased more than I intended.
Anastasia Beverly Hills Purchases
Carli Bybel Eyeshadow Palette | $45.00, CF
Looking at the Carli Bybel Palette, it may not seem like anything special. However, the swatches look magical. Their depth and high shine finish drew me in.
Mini Eyeshadow Primer | $13.00, CF
Although many consumers have major gripes with the Anastasia Beverly Hills Eyeshadow Primer packaging, most influencers seem to rave about the formula. Given that I lack a white-based primer I decided to pick up the mini version of this eye primer.
Undressed Liquid Lipstick Set | $45.00, CF
Anastasia Beverly Hill’s Pure Hollywood Liquid Lipstick used to be my go-to liquid lipstick. Over the years, I’ve decluttered or lost many of my ABH Liquid Lipsticks, so I was intrigued by the Undressed Liquid Lip bundle.
Ultimately, I chose to grab these liquid lipsticks because I want to re-familiarize myself with the ABH formula. Note: the bundle has terrible reviews on Sephora, so I am nervous at how these will look on my lips.
ColourPop x Disney Designer Purchases
I love the packaging of ColourPop’s newest Disney collaboration. The more I saw it, the more I wanted it. The Midnight Masquerade packaging is definitely my favorite of the three Disney Collaborations that have been released so far.
Beauty and the Beast Kit | $18.00, CF
I needed the Beauty and the Beast bundle due to my love of Belle. The Beauty and the Beast Kit comes with a Pressed Powder Blush in the shade Enchanted Mirror and the Luxe Liquid Lip in the shade Beast. Both products seem like staple neutrals, and I’m intrigued to try the new Luxe Liquid Lip formula.
Note: you do not save any money buying the Princess bundles, so only buy them if you think you’ll enjoy both products.
Coronation Pressed Powder Highlighter | $10.00, CF (now discontinued)
At first, I had no interest in the highlighters within this collection because I had a negative experience with the Villains highlighters. Read my ColourPop x Disney Villains review here. When I realized that the new highlighters did not have the same duo-chrome flip, I became more interested. Coronation is a stunning champagne pearl highlighter.
Court of Miracles Pressed Powder Blush | $10.00, CF
Court of Miracles is a vibrant coral blush unlike anything in my collection that immediately called my name. Plus, have you seen the beautiful Esmerelda illustration on this blush?
Kissin’ a Frog Pressed Powder BlushÂ | $10.00, CF
Out of all the cheek products in this collection, Kissin’ a FrogÂ called to me the most. I own very few terra-cotta blushes and I love the way this is vibrant while still looking natural.
Midnight Masquerade Palette | $22.00, CF
I judged the Midnight Masquerade Palette when I first saw the promo pictures. The color story is basic. The bold array of dark mattes on the bottom row of this palette ultimately persuaded me to buy this palette. Read my in-depth review on the ColourPop Midnight Masquerade Palette.
ColourPop Fall Collection
In all candor, I purchased these items simply because I was stressed and I knew I had some wiggle room to shop more during the two weeks when I pushed back my No Buy.
A Starlet is Born Bundle | $38.00, CF (bundle discontinued)
Originally I only intended to purchase the false lash trio from ColourPop, but the Burgundy Eye products really pulled on my basic New England girl heartstrings. Needless to say, the Starlet is Born Bundle hopped right into my cart. Products included in this bundle: Mami, Ms., and Queenie False Lashes, Joy Ride Creme Gel Color, Joy Ride Creme Gel Liner, Wine O’ Clock BFF Mascara.
Burgundy + Rose Nail Decal Set | $7.00, CF (now discontinued)
Did I need the Burgundy + Rose Nail Decals? No. Not at all. But I couldn’t resist the design and the nostalgia factor of purchasing these. (Sale Price: $6.30 USD)
You Should See Me in a Crown Palette | $40.00, CF
I hate myself for how badly I wanted this bundle after seeing it on Instagram. You Should See Me in a Crown is literally Fall in a palette. I love it. While I already owned a few of the shades in this pre-made, curated single eyeshadow palette, I opted to pick this up during myÂ No Buy gap. See swatches of all my single ColourPop Pressed Eyeshadows.
Shades included in the palette:
- Row 1: Ringer (Metallic Champagne), Running Late (Matte Creamy Orange), Anthem (Metallic Bright Pinky Copper), Heavy Glam (Vibrant Duochrome Orange with Pink flip), Milli (Metallic Intense Penny Copper)
- Row 2: Let Me Explain (Metallic Ivory), Wake Up Call (Matte Warm Sand), Over It (Metallic Peach with Gold flip), Paradiso (Metallic Violet)**, Imperial (Soft Red Orange), I Owe You (Matte Mid-Tone Orange)
- Row 3: Board Shorts (Metallic Bronze), Renegade (Soft Rose Gold Pressed Glitter with Copper Sheen), Not Ok (Metallic Burnt Orange), Mr. Sandman (Icy Rose with a Silver sheen)**, Thank U, Next (Metallic Rosy Bronze with Copper Duo-Chrome flip)**, Material Girl (Metallic Truffle Brown with Golden sheen)
- Row 3: Heart 2 HeartÂ (Metallic Warm-Toned Gold), Conundrum (Matte Warm Brown), High Society (Metallic Tangerine with Golden flip), Feathered (Matte Rich Chocolate Brown), Facet (Matte Deep Red-Brown), Martian (Matte Warm Terracotta with Gold Flecks), Let’s Do It (Matte Blackest Black)**
*Shades with an asterisk are shades that I already own as a single; **Shades with a double asterisk are shades that I already own in a palette
Fenty Beauty Holiday Collection
The Fenty Beauty Gloss Bomb is my all-time favorite gloss formula. Period. As soon as I saw the mini gloss kits that were being released for the holidays I knew I had to have them. Why? I love minis and I love this formula.
Fenty Beauty Glossy Posse Bundle | $42.00, CF
Not only did I want the Glossy PosseÂ because this is a set of minis. Given that I’ve already needed to remove the stopper on my Fenty Glow Mini Lip Gloss, I felt comfortable making this purchase.
Bomb Baby Bundle | $24.00 , CF (now discontinued)
The Bomb Baby Bundle (now discontinued) is a mini set that features a miniÂ Killawatt Freestyle Highlighter in the shade Sand Castle* and a mini Lip Gloss in the shade $weet Mouth.* I love minis and I love the Fenty Glosses, so I added this to my cart as well.
Miscellaneous Beauty Buys
Lemonhead L.A. Euphoria Glitter Bundle | $98.00, CF
Lemonhead L.A. is an editorial, indie brandÂ that is well known and well-loved for its glitter paste and glitter gels that were originally made for film and television use. When the Euphoria bundle launched earlier this Fall, I stopped myself from buying it. However, during my No Buy gap, I jumped at the chance to grab this glitter bundle. I was afraid to lose the ability to buy it forever. (Price: $75.00)
Pat McGrath Labs – Dark Star 006 Ultra Suede Brown Kit | $130.00
I blame Instagram for this purchase. Instagram hounded me with 50% off Ads for Pat McGrath’s sale. At first, I resisted the sale. However, the more I kept getting hit with the ads, the more my resolve weakened.
When the Dark Star 006 Ultra Suede Brown Kit came back in stock, I jumped at the chance to pick this up. (Sale Price: $65.00)
2019 Beauty Low Buy October Update Takeaway: A Low-Buy Is Not Enough for Me
When I started my Beauty Low Buy this past May, my intention was to correct my horrifying makeup spending. Initially, I hoped that sticking to a strict budget would be helpful. But here is the problem: I kept saying I wanted to change. However, I wasn’t doing enough to change the habits that lead to my overconsumption. I refused to hold myself accountable and kept letting my anxiety or sadness dictate my spending.
Having had major success with No Buys in the past, I moved away from my Beauty Low Buy.
I am now officially on another No Buy Challenge. However, I reserve the right to reassess my No Buy at the six-month mark. August 2020 Update:Â If it wasn’t evident from my 2019 Beauty Low Buy October update, trying to go on No Buys triggered me to panic-spend. As a result, I am not longer attempting to complete a total No Buy at this time.
As anticipated, I ended up “panicking” and purchased a ton of stuff right before the start of my No Buy. I purchased more than I thought I would – largely because I review products on my blog. A large part of me was afraid I’d run out of products to review over the next year.
Have you ever partook in a Low Buy or a No Buy? What advice would you share to anyone embarking on this type of challenge?0