February 2020 Boxycharm Unboxing February 17, 2020
This February marks the end of my 6-month subscription to Boxycharm. I felt a rush of nervous anticipation regarding the February 2020 Boxycharm box. Would this month’s box be compelling enough for me to resubscribe or would I finally unsubscribe from Boxycharm?
Was the February 2020 Boxycharm worth the $25.00 price tag? Please keep reading for my unboxing and thoughts on the February 2020 Boxycharm!
Ciate London, Pur Cosmetics, QMS Medicosmetics, KvD Vegan Beauty, and Alamar Cosmetics
Disclaimer: Links with an asterisk (*) are affiliate links, which means that I may make a small commission if you make a purchase using my link. Please note: I pay for my own Boxycharm subscription. All opinions are 100% my own.
What was in the February 2020 Boxycharm Box?
Alamar Cosmetics – Complexion Brush Trio| $36.00, CF, Vegan
How beautiful are the Alamar Cosmetics Complexion brushes?! Not only do the orange-gold handles look so luxurious, but I love the variety in the brush shapes. This trio includes a fluffy brush, dense brush, and angled brush.
These synthetic brushes are Cruelty-Free and Vegan.
Ciate London – Everyday Vacay Coconut Setting Powder | $22.00, CF, Vegan
The Everyday Vacay Coconut Setting Powder promises to provide wearers with a long-lasting, crease-free, soft-focus finish to the skin without causing any flashback. I wish this product did not contain talc. Ny hope is to transition to talc-free loose setting powders moving forward, Nevertheless, I’ll use this powder.
The Everyday Vacay Coconut Setting Powder is Cruelty-Free and Vegan.
KvD Vegan Beauty – Cake Pencil Liner | $20.00, CF, Vegan
Now that I am purchasing from KvD again, I the Cake Pencil Liner excited me. KvD’s Tattoo Liner is my all-time favorite liquid liner formula, so I am hopeful I’ll enjoy this liner!
The KvD Vega Beauty Cake Pencil Liner is Cruelty-Free and Vegan.
Pur Cosmetics – 4-In-1 Correcting Primer Energize & Rescue| $36.00, CF, Vegan
According to Pur, the 4-In-1 Energize & Rescue Correcting Primer* soothes and smoothes the skin. Also, it creates a smooth canvas. The primer is packed with good-for-your-skin ingredients from probiotics to coconut and aloe. I am curious to see how this performs compared to other brightening primers in my collection.
The Pur Cosmetics 4-In-1 Correcting Energize & Rescue Primer is Cruelty-Free and Vegan.
QMS Medicosmetics – Intensive Eye Cream | $135.00, CF
I gasped when I saw the price of the QMS Medicosmetics Intensive Eye Cream*. Undoubtedly, this is the most expensive eye cream that I have ever tried in my life. The price alone makes me curious to try this.
So Was the February 2020 Boxycharm Box Worth It?
Honestly, when I opened the February 2020 Boxycharm Box I rush of excitement. Then, a wave of disappointment followed. At first, I screamed internally when I saw the Alamar Cosmetics brushes in my box. I was in love with these brushes soon as I saw photos of them teased on the IndieMakeupSpotlight Instagram page.
However, once I looked at the sparse contents of my box, the initial excitement faded immediately. In fact, I literally exclaimed OMG WTF is this really it? This is THE most disappointing box that I’ve gotten!
Next, disappointment gave way for anger. I questioned the value of this month’s box. Already knowing the price ranges of the makeup-related products in this box, I set out to confirm my suspicion that the brand misrepresented the box value. However, I was shocked to realize that the tiny tub of eye cream in the February 2020 Boxycharm was worth $135.00.
I’ve said this in previous Boxycharm unboxing posts, but I take issue when Boxycharm includes one ultra high-value item in boxes. These supposedly luxurious products inflate the value of the box. In the end, I prefer to receive a mix of 5 mid-range products that I like as opposed to one high-end product (that I may or may not like) and a bunch of duds.
Rating: 2.5/5 Stars
So did I keep my Boxycharm subscription?
No. This month’s disappointing box convinced me to cancel my subscription (for the time being). At the end of the day, I own SUCH a large makeup collection. As such, it pains me to expand the size of my already massive collection with products that I feel lukewarm about.
Is Boxycharm bad? NO – not by any means. In fact, Boxycharm is one of the best beauty subscription box available. I am still blown away that they provide full-sized prestige beauty products to consumers at such a steep discount. Ultimately, Boxycharm is best for anyone who is just getting to makeup or skincare.
Read my thoughts on the previous month’s box or on the brand new, TrendMood Box Volume 3.
Are you beauty obsessed just like me? Did you enjoy my February 2020 Boxycharm unboxing? Let’s connect on social media: Instagram | Twitter | Pinterest | Bloglovin’ | Influenster
What did you think about the February 2020 Boxycharm items? Do you think I fluffed up by canceling my subscription? Please let me know in the comments below.
beauty beauty haul beauty subscription boxycharm boxycharm february 2020 boxycharm unboxing makeup makeup haul subscription box subscription box unboxing
makeupmuddle says
February 17, 2020 at 7:07 amOh no what a shame you were disappointed. It’s always a shame when a beauty box disappoints xo
Makeup Muddle
The Newbury Girl says
February 17, 2020 at 8:00 pmYeah it was a bummer but it made my decision to cancel much easier!
Lana Likes says
February 17, 2020 at 8:06 amI always get nervous about subscribing to boxes. I’m always worried I’ll be disappointed, just like you were. Some of these items are actually quite expensive though, I wasn’t expecting that!
The Newbury Girl says
February 17, 2020 at 8:00 pmI really wasn’t expecting it either lol! I literally gasped when I realized how expensive the eye cream is!
Athena Christy ☽️✨ says
February 17, 2020 at 2:00 pmOh no, that’s a shame. I honestly I would have loved more products too. That eye cream is too expensive. I love the brushes though!
—Athena Christy
The Newbury Girl says
February 17, 2020 at 7:57 pmThe brushes really are the standout product in this box – overall, I really love Alamar as a brand!!
sundaydahlias says
February 17, 2020 at 4:02 pmSuch a shame, I hope the next one is better! That’s what makes me cautious about beauty subscription boxes.
https://sundaydahlias.com
The Newbury Girl says
February 17, 2020 at 7:54 pmThis was definitely a bummer, but I’m happy to have gotten a chance to try this box out!
jennifertarheelreader says
February 17, 2020 at 5:53 pmThat’s too bad about this box and the subscription overall, LP, but I really appreciate your thoughts on it and how it may be good for those newer to makeup.
The Newbury Girl says
February 17, 2020 at 7:53 pmI agree completely – I think ultimately this is better for people who own much smaller makeup collections than I do. However, if Boxy were to offer their Luxe box as a seasonal subscription that would be a bigger pull for me to try again.
nortoncharity says
February 17, 2020 at 6:18 pmAwe that is disappointing! I have never done a subscription box before because I am scared that will happen to me too. I don’t want to pay for something I don’t really like or need!
The Newbury Girl says
February 17, 2020 at 7:52 pmIn theory, I like subscription boxes, but in practicality, I often love and use the items in my box way less than those I purchase on my own.
Alex Grace says
February 19, 2020 at 4:06 amI think you made the right decision, it’s the nature of any subscription box but unless you feel more happy about it than disappointed you shouldn’t use your money on it xx
The Newbury Girl says
February 19, 2020 at 10:07 pmI agree with you – I think the potential to be wow’d is what kept me hooked, but ultimately I tend to appreciate products I buy myself more!
Castles and Hurricanes says
February 20, 2020 at 3:07 pmYeah, I feel like it’s kind of ridiculous to include an eye cream that is THAT expensive in a box like this; the purpose is to try a variety of products, so it would be best to give items that are in relatively the same price range. While it would be fun to try a random expensive product, it doesn’t really seem like it’s something the majority of people would repurchase if they like it simply because it’s a lot more expensive than the products they normally buy. Those brushes are really pretty though!
The Newbury Girl says
February 25, 2020 at 9:59 pmI totally agree with you – sometimes these items just feel like they’re thrown in to up the value of the box unnecessarily. Was a bummer, BUT I think it was for the best since deep down I knew I needed to cancel this subscription.
Simone | Beautymone says
February 22, 2020 at 9:18 amYeah I totally agree with you on this, I think some of these boxes are a bit disappointing and I would’ve cancelled my subscription too. I still think the Boxycharm overall is a great idea and probably the best box out there but a couple of boxes were a bit ‘meh’.
The Newbury Girl says
February 25, 2020 at 10:05 pm100% – I wish TrendMood would turn her boxes into a subscription service OR that Boxycharm would allow people to subscribe to Boxyluxe as a standalone service! I would do either of those in a heartbeat!
PoojaG says
February 28, 2020 at 5:20 pmIt’s sad that you were disappointed but it makes sense that you stopped your subscription.
The Newbury Girl says
February 29, 2020 at 4:31 pmhonestly, I think it was a relief. It made the decision much easier for me.
Hunida says
March 12, 2020 at 9:44 pmI know we already talked about this but, I so agree about the brushes. They are just gorge. & is there a reason you’re staying away from powders that aren’t talc-free? I need to be more aware of ingredients & what they do.
Also, curious what changed your mind to start purchasing from KVD again? I hope you liked the liner if you’ve tried it! I can’t believe the price tag on that QMS eye cream either. I almost added it onto my box for only $12 during the popup sale but, I held back. Can’t wait to hear your thoughts on it & that primer too! I’ve read such mixed reviews about the PUR brand.
I totally understand your disappointment with this month’s box & not wanting to add more products to your huge collection. I would so rather have 5 mid-range products over just 1 super high value one, too! I hate that!
Thanks for sharing what you got, LP!! ♡
The Newbury Girl says
March 12, 2020 at 9:52 pmSo when it comes to beauty & personal care products talc is a controversial ingredient. Talc on its own is not problematic, BUT Talc is often found near to and mined with Asbestos, which is a known carcinogen.
Talc is meant to go through a refinement process to remove asbestos; however, it can still be found in small traces…. and is often found in very cheaply made cosmetics that are manufactured abroad. (If you’re up for some reading, check out the Claire’s makeup scandal.)
At this time I am still purchasing eyeshadows and pressed powders that contain talc, but do not feel comfortable using loose talc-based powders (especially those manufactured outside of the US). This is simply bc it is easier to inhale a loose powder than a pressed one. (This is the reason why I no longer apply loose powders with a powder brush …. only my beauty sponge or powder puff).
I haven’t tried the KvD liner yet! I am purchasing again bc my issues were with the brand’s founder. Won’t go into it here – but there were some very bad scandals. (I try to stay away from controversial brands or brand owners). Since she was forced to sell back her shares and is no longer affiliated with the brand, I no longer feel compelled to stop shopping. The Tattoo Liner is still my all-time fave liquid liner (although Fenty is close…… but that make sense since LMVH/Kendo Labs own both brands lol).
Hunida says
March 14, 2020 at 7:17 pmWow, LP! You are so in-the-know. Seriously, thank you so much for always explaining to me. <3 I think I'll be staying away from talc in my loose powders now, too! & interesting to know that KvD & Fenty are made in the same labs!