Bad or Rad | Persona Cosmetics Identity Palette Review

Persona Cosmetics Identity Palette Review, Swatches, and Demo

Founded in 2016 by makeup artist and beauty blogger, Sona Gasparian, Persona Cosmetics aims to provide beauty lovers with high-quality products that make everyone look and feel good. Since launching in 2015, the brand released a series of eyeshadow palettes, eyeliners, lip glosses, and liquid lipsticks. But is the indie darling worth the hype?

In today’s post, we’ll be diving into the brand’s first launch, The Identity Palette. Please keep reading for my thoughts on this neutral palette.

Persona Cosmetics Identity Palette Review, Swatches, and Demo

Persona Cosmetics Identity Palette Claims

According to the Persona Cosmetics website, the Identity Palette is loved by makeup lovers & pro artists, alike. The palette contains 12 buttery mattes and shimmers that are easy-to-use and versatile enough to create any looks, day or night.

The Identity Palette claims to be a curated, travel-friendly palette comprised of pigmented, buildable shadows that will last on the eye.

Persona Cosmetics Identity Palette Price & Packaging

The Identity Palette retails for $32.00 USD. The original Identity Palette comes in a lightweight, but sturdy, white cardboard case with a Parisian scene illustrated on the front. The cardboard does stain easily but can be cleaned with makeup remover or a wipe.

Persona will be rereleasing the Identity Palette in packaging that better fits with the brand’s sleek, minimalist design aesthetic. The new packaging is made out of plastic.

Persona Cosmetics Identity Palette Ingredients & CF Status

The mattes in this palette contain Talc, but this is not the primary ingredient in those shades.  Persona Cosmetics is Cruelty-Free, so they do not test on animals. Although a number of Persona products are Vegan, the brand’s eyeshadow palettes and kits are not vegan.

Persona Cosmetics Identity Palette Swatches

As always, I swatched this palette using my fingers over my bare arm without primer. Swatches are never a perfect indicator of quality, but they do provide clues as to a shadow’s pigmentation and ability to blend.

Persona Cosmetics Identity Palette Review, Swatches, and Demo - Finger Swatches
Finger Swatches of the Persona Identity Palette, from top to bottom: Humble, Sassy, Goal Digger, Seductive, Charming, Maverick, Bombshell, Goddess, Audacious, Chic, Bossy, Fearless

From top to bottom: Humble (Matte), Sassy (Shimmer), Goal Digger (Shimmer), Seductive (Shimmer), Charming (Matte), Maverick (Matte), Bombshell (Shimmer), Goddess (Shimmer), Audacious (Matte), Chic (Matte), Bossy (Shimmer), Fearless (Matte).

The matte shades are creamy and easy to blend. The mattes do produce a fair amount of kickback due to the powdery formula, but this doesn’t bother me.

The shimmers are not high-intensity, wet-looking metallics. Each shimmer shade is buildable and impactful for creating day-to-night looks.

Interestingly, there are three formula variations in the palette. Seductive and Goddess have different formulas compared to the other shimmers in the Identity palette. Bossy, the deep shimmer, has the same formula as the matte shades.

Persona Cosmetics Identity Palette Application & Wear-time

The matte shadows in the Identity Palette blend out with little effort. The pigmentation is consistent and buildable and the shadows play well with the other shades in this palette.

Despite having a few warm-tone shades, the overall vibe of the palette leans quite cool. A warm tone look can be created with the copper-colored shades. That being said, the darker shades do produce a bit of kickback, so I do get fallout under my eye when building up the deeper colors.

The shimmer shades in this palette are shiny, without looking overly wet or metallic. Initially, I thought my favorite shade would be Goddess, but Seductive is my favorite lid shade in this palette.

I am not crazy about the shades, Sassy or Bossy. These shadows have more of a satin finish on the eye. I don’t consider them a true shimmer.

Bad or Rad Review | Persona Cosmetics Identity Eyeshadow Palette Review | Demonstration on Oily Lids
Persona Cosmetics Identity Eyeshadow Palette Demo

Without a primer, these shadows do not last on my lid more than a few hours but will last all day on my oily lids when worn overtop a base. This is normal for me with all shadows due to my oily skin.

Where Can You Purchase the Persona Cosmetics Identity Palette?

Persona Cosmetics is sold online via the brand’s e-commerce site and through Ulta. Orders that are $40.00 USD+ qualify for free shipping on Persona’s website and $35.00 USD+ at Ulta. Please note, the Persona website does ship to over 190 countries.

Persona Cosmetics Identity Palette Review, Swatches, and Demo
Can you tell how much I love this brand? 🙂

Final Thoughts on Persona Cosmetics Identity Palette

Although the Identity Palette was the brand’s first release, it was not my first purchase from the brand. This palette has become my go-to nude palette when I want to rock an elevated, neutral look.

According to one of my friends, these shadows are “an edgy take on a natural look that enhances the eye.” I highly recommend this eyeshadow palette to anyone looking for a neutral palette with a cool undertone.

It speaks such volumes that Persona was able to completely sell out of the Identity Palette stock at Ulta. I can’t wait to see what the repackaged palette looks. If you’re a more of a colorful eyeshadow fan than the Identity 2 Palette may be a great option for you.

Persona Cosmetics has become one of my favorite brands. I appreciate that each new launch is well thought out and that each brand extension is curated. Sona’s expertise as a professional MUA and an influencer truly help the brand shine.

I own nearly every single product the brand has released, so expect more reviews in the future. Check out my review of the Persona Lip Glosses.

For more on influencer & celebrity makeup lines, check out my Beau-Tea Talk #2 covering the rise of celebrity makeup brands.

New to Persona Cosmetics? Please consider using my referral link for 15% off your first purchase. If you make a purchase I will receive 5% cashback for the sale, but please know that I’ve been purchasing from Persona long before I had a code. I would never recommend products I didn’t truly love.

Let’s connect on social media: Instagram | Twitter | Pinterest | Bloglovin’ | Influenster

Love indie brands just as much as I do? Check out my indie beauty roundups (volume I, volume II, and volume III) featuring indie brands that I love and want to try more of this year.


Have you heard of Persona Cosmetics before? What is your favorite indie brand? Please let me know in the comments below.

17 thoughts on “Bad or Rad | Persona Cosmetics Identity Palette Review

  1. I’ve heard so many amazing things about Persona Cosmetics, especially the Identity palette. It looks so stunning and I’m gutted I can’t get persona Cosmetics in the UK. I love how different the identity palette is to all the other palettes on the market which is such a unique selling point of it. Once again I love your reviewing style and can’t wait to see more reviews from you lovely!
    Alex xxx

  2. I’ve never tried this brand but I’ll check it out some time. I’m not huge on eyeshadow palettes but I do like more natural nude shades so I’ll try this one out.

  3. Oh very cool! Again, a brand I’ve never heard of but nice that they are doing really well to sell out, lol! I love the shimmery shade on you, that shade looks really lovely 🙂 The natural / nude shades in this palette are really pretty!

  4. Persona Cosmetics sounds interesting! I like that they keep things to the basics. The pricing of the palette isn’t so bad either. I love the colors of the swatches. I love the look of your eyeshadow! It is great that Persona gave you a good impression overall. Thanks for sharing your thoughts!

    Nancy ♥ exquisitely.me

  5. Love that the brand is cruelty-free & also sold at Ulta, not just online. The swatches turned out so well & I love the look your created! ♡ Can’t believe they were completely sold out. I can’t wait to see how they redesign their palette & I’m looking forward to seeing what else this brand releases– super cool how you own every product so far!

    1. I’m def curious to see how the redesign the packaging of this palette. Sadly, I don’t love the Identity 2 Palette color scheme as much, but I’m hopeful they’ll release blushes or bronzers soon!

  6. I really love how you described it- neutral but edgy. It’s such a fantastic palette I love mine and I would repurchase it if I hit pan- which is possible since I used it so much last year.

Leave a Reply